I don't see the point of this? Well, lets critic this a little:

1] First off, Ash only had 2 fully evolved Starter Pokemon, it has only been seen that Ash's 2 Sinnoh Starters will be at their Mid-Form, so we can't be sure if either one will be at final evolution.

2] The Petalburg Gym was not an official gym battle, so only Kanto & Sinnoh shair the trait of Ash losing to the first gym leader, since Norman is the 5th gym leader also.

3] I EVEN catch the Normal/Flying type of any region first, get a Starter and get the other 2(Grass/Fire/Water), Pichu/Pikachu/Raichu, and some other one.

4] I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, don't see where you are going with this, just seems like a random post but I won't judje, I have made random posts myself.

1.) I said he would MOST LIKELY have a final evolution of a sinnoh starter seeing as he already has 2 mid forms with one and a half seasons to go, assuming he goes to the Battle Fronteir again.

2.)By "a gym battle ash partcicpats in" I mean a battle fought in a gym, official or not (i guess that one was a little unclear)

3.) I totally know what you mean with the whole normal/flying pokemon logic as i most commonly do this as well, but I am simply saying that after three regions of normal flying types, you'd think that the writers would try to give a little more variety to the fourth, just so it isn't too much like the gamer's experience (or at least not make two of them evolve in the same way. To be fair, each normal/flying tpe had a little different scenario: pidgeotto was caught in its second form, noctowl was shiny, tailow was caught in its first stage, and starly was caught in its first stage but evolved twice. Not a big difference but it shows some effort.

I am really sorry for this random post but I just wanted to share my thoughts

Uh oh, expect a message from pikachu315111, saying Dawn will get a Cherubi/Cherrim. Well It is going to be Eevee first and then Leafeon but I have high hopes for Chikorita.